Do You Have Migraine Without Knowing It? What a 601-Woman Study Found

In a study of 601 women, half of those who met criteria for migraine had not identified it themselves, while women who said they had migraine were almost always right.

On this page · 8 sections
  1. The Question Behind the Study
  2. How the Study Worked
  3. What the Study Found
  4. Aura, Vestibular Migraine, and Menstrual Migraine
  5. Why People Miss Their Own Migraine
  6. Limitations to Keep in Mind
  7. What This Means for You
  8. References

The Question Behind the Study

A lot of migraine research starts with one basic question: "Do you have migraine?" Population surveys, prevalence estimates, and even some clinic triage systems lean on that answer. If people tend to get it wrong, the numbers built on it are off too, and some people with migraine never get offered treatment because nobody, including them, has named the problem.

A new study published in BMC Neurology tested how well that self-label holds up. Researchers in Melbourne, Australia, compared what 601 women said about their own migraine history with a diagnosis made by a headache neurologist who did not know what each woman had reported.

When women said they had migraine, they were almost always right. When they said they did not, they were wrong a large share of the time.

How the Study Worked

This was a single-center, prospective cross-sectional study at a women's mental health clinic inside a tertiary hospital. Women attending between January 2016 and June 2025 recorded on their intake form whether they had ever had migraine, and the treating psychiatrist confirmed that answer during the visit.

Later, a neurologist with headache expertise interviewed each woman by phone and applied the International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition (ICHD-3) criteria. The neurologist asked about head pain, prompted for associated symptoms, and followed up on answers rather than relying on a yes or no label. Women who said they did not have migraine were interviewed too, which is what made it possible to measure how often migraine goes unrecognized.

The team chose a mental health clinic on purpose. Headache was not the reason anyone came in, so the group was less likely to be stacked with people who already carried a headache diagnosis.

Who Was Included

Of 1,049 women seen at the clinic over the study period, 601 agreed to both the self-report and the neurologist interview. Their mean age was 40.0 years (range 14 to 76). About 60% were of reproductive age, 24.5% were perimenopausal, and 15.7% were postmenopausal.

The researchers had planned for at least 238 participants, expecting self-report and specialist diagnosis to agree about 95% of the time.

What the Study Found

Only 186 women (30.9%) said they had migraine. After the neurologist interview, 345 women (57.4%) met ICHD-3 criteria. Overall, the two diagnoses matched in 69.6% of women, well below the 95% the researchers had expected.

30.9%
Said they had migraine
186 of 601 women on their intake form
57.4%
Met migraine criteria
345 of 601 women after the neurologist interview
171
Missed diagnoses
Women with migraine who said they did not have it
93.6%
Self-report confirmed
Share of "yes" answers the neurologist agreed with

The table below shows how the answers lined up against the neurologist's diagnosis.

Neurologist diagnosis Woman said "I have migraine" Woman said "No migraine" Total
Has migraine 174 (correctly identified) 171 (missed) 345
No migraine 12 (incorrect "yes") 244 (correctly ruled out) 256
Total 186 415 601

Numbers from the study's confusion matrix. Percentages in the text are of all 601 women unless stated otherwise.

Reading the Numbers

The table shows two very different patterns. Of the 186 women who said yes, only 12 were wrong. Of the 345 women who had migraine, 171 had not identified it. That second group is the core finding: roughly half of the women with migraine in this clinic did not know they had it.

In diagnostic terms, self-report had a sensitivity of 50.4% and a specificity of 95.3%. Its positive predictive value was 93.6%, while the negative predictive value was 58.8%. Chance-corrected agreement (Cohen's kappa) was 0.424, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.354 to 0.493, which the authors describe as fair.

What These Terms Mean Here

Sensitivity (50.4%) is the share of women with migraine who said they had it.

Specificity (95.3%) is the share of women without migraine who correctly said no.

Positive predictive value (93.6%) is how often a "yes" was right. Negative predictive value (58.8%) is how often a "no" was right. Predictive values shift with how common a condition is in the group studied, so these exact figures belong to this clinic.

The researchers also checked whether education, paid employment, or receiving government benefits explained who missed their own diagnosis. None of them did. A bachelor's degree, a postgraduate degree, and employment were not linked to a mismatch, and the link with government benefits did not reach significance (p = 0.054).

Among the 256 women who did not meet migraine criteria, 231 (90.2%) did not have regular headaches at all. Another 13 had tension-type headache, and 9 had migraine-like attacks but fewer than the 5 lifetime attacks the criteria require.

Aura, Vestibular Migraine, and Menstrual Migraine

Women who named a specific feature of their migraine were usually right about it. The study was not designed to classify subtypes, but the neurologist recorded what women reported and what was confirmed.

Feature women reported Reported Confirmed by neurologist Notes
Migraine with aura 100 99 Visual aura in 91 of 99 (92.0%). The one revised case described brain fog before the headache, which fits the prodrome or headache phase.
Vestibular migraine 9 9 All 9 met ICHD-3 criteria
Menstrually related migraine 13 12 Confirmation was by interview only, without a prospective headache diary

The authors suggest aura and vestibular symptoms are dramatic enough that people often get worked up for stroke, seizures, or other causes before they ever see a headache specialist, so the label tends to arrive with a proper evaluation behind it. If you want to compare your own experience, our guides to aura characteristics in migraine and vestibular migraine walk through the features clinicians look for.

For menstrual migraine, the authors note that both over- and under-reporting are common when no diary is kept, so a few months of tracking attacks against the menstrual cycle is the standard way to confirm the pattern.

Why People Miss Their Own Migraine

The study did not test reasons directly, and the authors say more work is needed. They raise two possibilities: people may blame their attacks on something else, such as poor sleep, or they may not be familiar with what migraine looks like.

The authors also make the case for an interview over a checklist. A clinician can ask follow-up questions, catch a misunderstood question, and pick up other causes of head pain such as dental problems. Earlier research summarized in the paper points the same way, with migraine more often under-recognized than over-diagnosed, by both the public and physicians.

The authors note that people with missed or incorrect migraine diagnoses tend to have more emergency department visits, more consultations, and more inappropriate prescriptions. Undertreated migraine can also drift toward frequent use of acute medication, which raises the risk of medication overuse headache. Our medication overuse headache checker is a quick way to see whether your current pattern of painkiller or triptan use is a concern.

Limitations to Keep in Mind

The authors name two main limitations. First, the participants were women attending a specialist mental health clinic, and 448 of the 1,049 women seen over the study period were not included. Migraine was far more common in this group (57.4%) than in the general population, so the exact agreement and predictive values may not carry over to other settings. The direction of the finding, that migraine is under-recognized rather than over-recognized, matches earlier studies.

Second, the team did not collect reliable data on migraine frequency, age at onset, or chronicity, so the study cannot say whether under-recognition is worse in people with chronic migraine. Diagnoses were made by phone interview rather than an in-person exam, and only one neurologist made them.

The study measured diagnostic agreement. It did not follow women over time or test whether a new diagnosis changed their treatment or outcomes.

What This Means for You

If you have recurring headaches and have never called them migraine, this study is a reason to ask. Migraine attacks often come with nausea, sensitivity to light or sound, worsening with routine activity, and a need to lie down. Plenty of people with these attacks call them "bad headaches," "sinus headaches," or "stress headaches" for years.

  • Our 3-question migraine screening test takes about a minute and is a reasonable first step before an appointment.
  • Write down how often attacks happen, how long they last, and what comes with them. The printable appointment summary sheet puts this on one page for your physician.
  • If you have headache on many days each month, the chronic migraine calculator shows whether your pattern meets the threshold for chronic migraine, which changes which preventive options are on the table.

For clinicians, the authors suggest opportunistic headache screening in groups where migraine is common, including women seen in mental health settings. Given the strong links between migraine, depression, and anxiety covered in our article on migraine and depression, a few targeted headache questions at intake could identify people who would otherwise go untreated.

Key Takeaways
  • Among 601 women at an Australian mental health clinic, 30.9% said they had migraine, but 57.4% met diagnostic criteria on neurologist interview.
  • When women said they had migraine, a neurologist agreed 93.6% of the time.
  • Of the 345 women with migraine, 171 had not identified it themselves.
  • Self-reported aura and vestibular migraine were almost always confirmed.
  • Education and income measures did not explain who missed the diagnosis.
  • The group was a specialist clinic population, so the exact percentages may differ elsewhere.
Important Medical Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only and does not replace professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. A screening tool or article cannot diagnose migraine. If you have new, changing, or severe headaches, or headaches with neurological symptoms, talk with a physician promptly.

References

  1. Gunasekera L, Kulkarni J. Inaccuracy of self-reported migraine: insights from 601 paired assessments from a single-centre study in Australia. BMC Neurology. 2026;26(1). doi:10.1186/s12883-026-05268-8.
  2. Headache Classification Committee of the International Headache Society (IHS). The International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition. Cephalalgia. 2018;38(1):1-211. doi:10.1177/0333102417738202.

Guided practice

Alternate nostril breathing

A 5-minute guided practice for migraine prevention, from Unraveling Migraine. Captions are built into the video.

  • Prevention, not a rescue. Keep your usual medicine for migraine attacks.
  • Daily practice is what counts. The study behind it used 3 short sessions a day for 3 months.
  • Skip it or stop if your nose is blocked or it starts to feel like a strain.
Read the full guide and the research