Cerebral Torque Is Under Attack. Here's What Happened.
A psychologist blocked me before we had ever interacted, called me a troll, and sent me a legal threat. The same day, a one-star review hit my book. Here is the full record.
On this page · 6 sections
I started Cerebral Torque in 2021 with one rule. Say what the evidence says, even when it's unpopular. That rule has never made me many friends in the wellness corner of the internet. This week it got me a legal threat.
What started it
Before this month, I didn't know who Dr. Emily Kostelnik (@dremilykostelnik) was. She runs a practice called The Vestibular Psychologist. A follower sent me one of her posts, the way people often send me posts and profiles they think might be scams. It came through as "Message unavailable," and my follower wrote back, "You are blocked." She had blocked me before we had ever interacted. I had never commented on her posts, messaged her, or said a word about her.
On November 13 I posted two stories. The first showed my follower's message. The second was a screenshot of her profile with an eyes emoji. That was it. No claims, no criticism, nothing about her work.
Her response
Before I had looked into a single thing she says, she posted a story to her 64,000 followers, tagging my account. In it she called me "this Instagram troll" and wrote, "He perpetuates medical gaslighting." She also wrote that I don't "share [my] name or credentials."
I replied with a story tagging her, the only time I've tagged her. I said she was weaponizing her followers before I had even looked into her, and asked why someone with nothing to hide would react that way. I also answered her line about "evidence-based" options. Tested treatments don't help everyone. Untested ones haven't been shown to help anyone.

The email
That same afternoon she emailed me, with her attorney copied. Here it is in full.

It calls my stories harassment and threatens legal action. It doesn't point to a single statement it claims is false.
My response
I answered half an hour later. Here's most of what I sent.
I got your email. Mr. Barmasse is copied here.
I'm not removing anything. I stand by what I posted. Criticism of what you say and sell in public is not harassment, and calling it that doesn't make it so.
Your email doesn't identify a single statement that is false. If you believe one is, name it and show me why, and I'll look at it. Until then, there is nothing here for me to act on.
I will keep commenting on public claims about migraine and vestibular conditions, yours included, whenever I think patients are being misled. A legal threat won't change that.
She hasn't responded since.
The review
The same day, a one-star review titled "Who is The Author?" appeared on the Kindle edition of Unraveling Migraine. It makes the same point her story did, that I don't use my real name. It doesn't carry a Verified Purchase badge, and as of November 14 it was the only written review on the book below five stars.
The reviewer's only other reviews are for pickleball paddles and a Yankees T-shirt. When I searched the reviewer's name, it led to a public Instagram account under the same name, with several photos that include Dr. Kostelnik. I'm not sharing that account here because it has photos of children on it. I don't know who wrote the review. I reported it to Amazon on November 14, and they're looking at it.
I want to be careful here. If she wrote that review, asked someone else to, or knew about it and went along with it, that would say something worrying about the ethics of a licensed psychologist. It would also show how much she cares whether people living with migraine can find evidence-based resources. A one-star review on a migraine reference book doesn't hurt me nearly as much as it hurts the next person trying to decide whether to read it.
On the point it makes, Cerebral Torque is a pen name and I've never hidden that. My photo and my background are on the site. I keep my legal name off this work for my own privacy, and you don't need it to judge the book. The sources are listed in the book, so you can check them yourself. That's what evidence-based means.
Why I'm telling you this
Because this is how it usually goes. Someone starts to look at a public claim. The answer isn't evidence. It's a label, a pile-on, a threat, or a one-star review posted to hurt someone. That isn't criticism. It's cowardice. People living with migraine deserve better than that, and they deserve to see it when it happens.
Her story went out to her 64,000 followers, and as far as I can tell, none of them took her up on it. Nobody from her audience left a nasty comment. The only people who came after me were her and one friend who stepped in to defend her. Some of her followers probably looked at my page and agreed with what they saw, and the rest just didn't follow her lead. Either way, I'm grateful to the migraine community for seeing through such a strange response to someone wanting to fact-check a few claims.
On my end, nothing changes. Every guide is still free, every claim is still sourced, and if I get something wrong you can tell me at support@cerebraltorque.com and I'll fix it in the open. I won't take anything down because someone threatened me. I will take it down if someone shows me it's wrong.
I'll keep you updated as this situation develops. Thanks for sticking with me.
Cerebral Torque





